State Farm® Insurance Agent Andrew Stark

"Great communication and service"

"Tara Metzke was very easy and efficient to work with. She was also very patient while I was comparing rates and coverage options."

"Excellent, knowledgeable, responsive & customer-focused service. I really enjoyed my experience working with Nicky Mazur. She is TERRIFIC!"

"Tara was phenomenal..she met the need at the right price.."

"Alex was very helpful on finding coverage that was much more affordable."

"I feel safe with Andrew stark agency because they have the most patience and understanding in my situation. Thanks guys!"

"Tara was very helpful, very clear on her explanations, and helped me through the process in a very efficient manner"

"Very nice!! I see other people on here switched from AmFam as well! I felt guilty leaving my insurance company for as long as I have been with them, but I felt I was paying too much. Andrew helped me find the same coverage for a lot less and in a speedy manner! Update from 2025...Tara was amazing, so kind and patient and helped me with adding homeowners insurance to my policy"

"Tara was my agent and she deserves more then 5 stars:)"

"I’ve dealt with a decent amount of agents. Tara was kind, informative, and patient with all my questions. Def will stay with state farm now."

"Office staff is wonderful. Nicky did a great job helping me through the auto insurance process!"

"Savannah at Andrew Stark's State Farm Insurance was amazing. She assisted my 85 year old aunt and me, when we were at the DMV for a driver's license appointment. My aunt had just received her new auto insurance card, but had forgotten to put it in her wallet. We got to the DMV appt, and they asked for her auto insurance, she did not have the up to date card in her wallet! We anxiously called her agent, who was unavailable to take the call. Quickly, I Googled a State Farm Insurance provider in the area, and got this agency. We live in Illinois, they are located in Wisconsin. Savannah attempted by various ways to contact my aunt's agent, but was unsuccessful. She selflessly and quickly located and uploaded my aunt's insurance card and sent it to me and also the DMV. She saved the day! We appreciate her assistance so much!"

"Tara was great! Very responsive and quick with answers. We settled on a great coverage."

"Savannah was wonderful! Happy to work with Andrew stark state farm!"

"Tara helped me switch from progressive to state farm, saved me money and helped me understand the policies more as well. She was very helpful!"

"Andrew is the best! Everything I need is taken care of right away in a timely manner! I Highly recommend Andrew!"

"Alex and Sahvanna are the BEST! Very thorough, extremely knowledgeable, and professional. Please utilize them for all your insurance needs! You will be so happy you did!!!!"

"Great insurance agency"

"Tara did great…I’m glad I answered the phone, saved me some money plus it’s local..!! This woman was very informative and got strait to the point..! I’m very satisfied..!"

"Have been with Andrew’s for a few years now. Very friendly, caring, responsive, knowledgeable, and consistent. I can see ourselves staying in partnership with Andrew’s for the foreseeable future."

"Tara was great to work with! She was very helpful and worked around my schedule to help me switch and save. The process was quick and easy would definitely recommend to friends and family!"

"Wonderful very helpful and saved me a bunch from what I was paying. Highly recommend to see Tara Metzke in Mequon, WI"

"Alex helped me get started on my insurance quick and easy!!"

"I just switched from Progressive to State Farm and Tara not only made the whole process an absolute breeze, but was also a joy to talk to! I have had Progressive for quite a long time and never interacted with an agent or thought much about my policy. Working with Tara today was the first time I've ever felt genuinely valued by an insurance agency and I loved her genuine passion for the job. I can honestly say that I'm very happy to have Tara and her team in my corner now!"

"Andrew Starks team made insuring my new vehicle super easy. They were very friendly, knowledgeable, and flexible. I would recommend them to anyone!"